Close Close
Poll

Do you agree with Driver Only Operation on railways?

View the poll

McDonald advocates hydrogen power and more wires

Shadow Transport Secretary Andy McDonald has given his backing to hydrogen train technology, but warns that it should not come at the expense of further electrification.

The alternative fuel has recently emerged as a contender to replace ageing diesel multiple units (DMUs), due to its low emissions and emerging commercial viability. It also requires the introduction of less physical infrastructure than electrifying new routes - the gas can be carried in onboard tanks that are refuelled at the start and finish of daily diagrams, in a similar way to DMUs.

The technology, which combines hydrogen and oxygen in fuel cells to generate power instead of combustion, is currently being developed by students at the Birmingham Centre for Railway Research and Education (BCRRE). 

Meanwhile, hydrogen trains built by Alstom are currently on test in Germany, while the train manufacturer is also working with Eversholt to convert Class 321 electric multiple units to hydrogen power for use on the UK network (RAIL 840). 

Secretary of State for Transport Chris Grayling has described the technology’s introduction as “a priority” (RAIL 845), with the new East West Rail link cited as a possible route for deployment once construction of the line is complete in the mid-2020s.

Speaking on a visit to BCRRE on July 30, McDonald agreed that hydrogen offers clear environmental advantages over diesel traction, but he added that government should not use it as a way to avoid the cost and disruption associated with extending electrification across the network.

  • For the FULL story, read RAIL 859, published on August 15, and available digitally from August 11 on Android/iPad.

Comment as guest


Login  /  Register

Comments

  • AndrewJG8918 - 08/08/2018 04:59

    What about converting Class 317 EMU’s as Hydrogen trains or Bi-Mode trains to be used in the Southwest of England, Midlands and Northern England. Plus Northern Ireland could benefit having older trains that were built in England in the 1970’s/80’s and to help boost services in Northern Ireland and perhaps transfer the older British built trains to be cascaded to the Republic of Ireland to help them boost their railways with extra trains and extra services being added. Whilst England, Wales and Scotland will continue to have new trains, aswell to serve the railways across the country and to serve towns and cities with new trains built and in service. Including places-Manchester, London & Southeast, Birmingham & West Midlands, Leeds & Yorkshire, North of England, Glasgow, Edinburgh, Newcastle, Cornwall, East Anglia & Essex, Swansea and Cardiff.

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register
  • AndrewJG8918 - 10/08/2018 20:27

    Hydrogen Class 321’s is the best way to maintain these iconic British built passenger commuter trains that were built in 1988 and operated on the West Coast Main Line & Abbey branch line, Great Northern East Coast Main Line, London-Norwich Great Eastern Main Line and Essex branch lines and Doncaster-Leeds service operated by Northern. As they have still serve London Liverpool Street which they are operated on Greater Anglia services but to be replaced by the Bombardier Aventra Class 720 and Stadler Flirt Class 745 EMU trains that are to replace the Class 321’s and other units including the Class 317’s. And some have been transferred to ScotRail as Class 320’s. Which ScotRail could inherit few more Class 320’s (converted Class 321’s) from Greater Anglia to operate alongside with the Class 318’s. As the Class 314’s are to be replaced by the Class 385’s. When more Class 385’s are in service.

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register

RAIL is Britain's market leading modern railway magazine.

Download the app

Related content