COVER STORY: Northern to be axed... calls grow for TPE to follow

Should Government strip Arriva of the current Northern franchise, the same should happen to TransPennine Express.

That’s the verdict of Northern Powerhouse Partnership Director Henri Murison, commenting after Secretary of State for Transport Grant Shapps told the BBC on January 2 that he intended to axe the current deal for Northern.

Shapps subsequently elaborated that this was the process he had started in October, which will result in either Arriva retaining the franchise via a Direct Award or an Operator of Last Resort being appointed to run the franchise instead.

It’s not just Northern under threat. There is also a possibility of South Western Railway going back into public ownership and calls for Abellio to lose West Midlands Trains.

Additionally, staff from the Operator of Last Resort (OLR) have been assessing Great Western Railway since last October, as the current Direct Award is due to finish at the end of March. Sources expect FirstGroup to receive a third Direct Award, although there is the option for Government to take it back in-house.

Speaking on TPE, Murison said: “The comments by the Transport Secretary reflect the position as it has stood for some time now - Northern will need to become a short-term contract renegotiated to reflect the long-term structural issues, or will lose the franchise.

“It’s often wrongly believed that Northern is responsible for the abject performance of the whole of the rail network in the North. This is not the case - TransPennine Express is equally as bad, if not worse, having mismanaged the new train timetable introduction last December.

“It’s clear that government are rightly listening to Northern leaders’ calls to take action, and our clear view is that both Northern and TPE should be treated the same by the Transport Secretary. The same process under way for Northern should be triggered with TransPennine for its unacceptable performance levels.”

Murison also warned against splitting Northern into two, saying that was a “knee-jerk response and would likely make problems worse”.

A Department for Transport spokesman told RAIL that the suggestion of splitting Northern was not something the Government had considered.

“As the Transport Secretary said, he has started a process which would either strip Northern of its franchise or issue a short-term contract to them,” he said.

“We are taking action to ensure passengers in the North get a better service and we will provide an update in due course.”

  • For the FULL story, read RAIL 896, out now.
  • For the FULL story on South Western Railway, read RAIL 896, out now.
  • For the FULL story on West Midlands Trains, read RAIL 896, out now.

Comment as guest

Login  /  Register


  • John Harper - 20/01/2020 17:45

    Perhaps an opening to tweek the franchise map as First also is SWR in trouble and Aviva is also in a weak position. Why not put SWR and Northern on operating contracts but in exchange insist TPE, Hull Trains & East Coast are transferred to LNER, along with Grand Central. Grand Union should be folded into Avanti. That still leaves WMT and LNW to fix, if required put WMT into an operating contract run by Chiltern and LNW into Avanti . Cuts operator from 19 passenger train operators to 12. If Anglia fails (which it might) offer C2C an operating contract and fold it into one company.

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register
    • Tim Diggle - 21/01/2020 11:42

      Before going overboard with attacking the TOCs perhaps the critics should examine the performance of DfT and Network Rail. I am a simple bystander and traveler but feel that the problems faced by these 2 TOCs are more deep seated than simple inefficiency. I think I heard that the services required by the franchises were dependent upon certain infrastructure improvements (most notably electrification around the north and capacity increases around Manchester Piccadilly through lines ) none of which have been delivered by NR.

      Reply as guest

      Login  /  Register

RAIL is Britain's market leading modern railway magazine.

Download the app

Related content